Where to Find the Best Pie in Cincinnati

This post is sponsored by Broadway in Cincinnati.

Inspired by Broadway in Cincinnati’s upcoming musical, Waitress, I thought it would be fun to check out some of the pies makers we have right here in Cincinnati.

Waitresses from Broadway in Cincinnati's Waitress the Musical
Waitress the Musical

Waitress is the story of Jenna – an expert pie maker and a waitress. Jenna dreams of a way to get out of her small town and her loveless marriage. A baking contest in a nearby county and the town’s new doctor may offer her a chance at a fresh start, while her fellow waitresses offer their own recipes for happiness.

Waitress will be at The Aronoff Center Jan. 9-21, 2018. Click here to learn more.

While Jenna is an expert pie maker, I personally find pies to be a tough thing to master. You have to get just the right flakiness going on with that crust. Your filling has to be well balanced – not too sour and not too sweet. The consistency has to be spot on as no one likes a runny pie filling.

Best Pies in Cincinnati

I recently reached out to the 365Cincinnati Facebook page readers and asked them to recommend their favorite place to get a slice of pie in Cincinnati. And then we went out for a little Pie Tour.

Check out what we found…

O Pie O

Honey Vinegar Pie at O Pie O in Walnut Hills

This place was mentioned over and over as having great pie… and you all were right! They’re known for their Honey Vinegar Pie (pictured above), a cream filling in a flaky crust. The top is just a bit crunchy (think Creme Brulee), giving the filling a great contrast of crunchy and smooth.

The handcrafted pies from O Pie O use the best in seasonal ingredients and they source locally whenever they can.

O Pie O in Walnut Hills

I was surprised to learn that O Pie O is not just about dessert. They offer a number of savory pies (chicken pot pie anyone?), empanadas, sandwiches, and salads. Wine and beer are on the menu and they even have a Happy Hour.

O Pie O can be found at 1527 Madison Road in East Walnut Hills.


Hyde’s Restaurant

Hyde’s has to rank up there with one of my favorite finds of 2017. This place is an old school diner and well worth the drive (it’s in Hamilton).

Hydes Family Restaurant in Hamilton Ohio

We had lunch followed by the best Banana Cream Pie I’ve ever had – seriously. Whole banana slices are hidden in the creamy filling and the meringue on top! Just look at it!

Banana Cream Pie at Hyde's in Hamilton Ohio

You can buy pie by the slice or your can order an entire pie (call ahead to place your order for whole pies). You won’t be sorry!

Hyde’s Restaurant is located at 130 South Erie Highway in Hamilton, Ohio.


Bluebird Bakery

Another fan favorite, Bluebird Bakery is in Glendale. They serve up all kinds of baked goodies and are well known for their pies.

Triple Berry Pie at Bluebird Bakery in Glendale Ohio

I had the Triple Berry Pie, covered in a beautiful lattice crust topper. It had a nice fruity punch and the fruit filling had the perfect balance of sweetness and tartness.

Bluebird Bakery in Glendale

Bluebird Bakery is located at 29 Village Square in Glendale

 

Do YOU have any great pie places to recommend? Let us know in the comments.

Waitress the Musical

And don’t miss it!

Waitress will be at The Aronoff Center from January 9 through January 21, 2018.

About Bridgett Raffenberg 782 Articles
Cincinnati lover, Mom, wife, travel enthusiast, Wordpress lover (not necessarily in that order). Founder of 365 Things to do in Cincinnati.

6 Comments

  1. Storey’s restaurant. I guarantee you will love the atmosphere and homemade pies they are known for in Greensburg IN. We follow Cincinnati news so not too far to drive and a great town to visit.

  2. Piebird. At Covington Farmer’s market. They also sell to Folk School Coffee and The Gruff.

    Amazing pies. Simply amazing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*